Competitor Smear Tactics: Deceptive Advertising and Negative Publicity

What We Mean by Anti-Advertising Against Competitors

People often use the phrase “anti-advertising against competitors” to mean black PR in all its forms, aimed at discrediting a competitor’s reputation. From that perspective, any circulation of negative information about a company counts as anti-advertising.

This is partly true. In black PR, however, we also use the term in a narrower sense. We mean a method of competitive confrontation in which two rival companies are pushed into conflict and an information war begins between them.

Below, we will examine the method through practical examples.

How Reputation Conflicts Develop Between Competitors

When several competitors are operating in the same market and the budget for a campaign to discredit their reputations is limited, it can make sense to pit several market players against each other so they begin running information campaigns against one another.

This can save us substantial money: we do not have to spend the budget on discrediting every competitor at once. Instead, we can use methods that provoke other market participants into mutual accusations, make them trade accusations and spend their own budgets on an information war.

The idea is to use advertising tools without becoming directly involved in the conflict between competitors.

Competitor Smear Tactics: Reviews and Negative Publicity

The principle is simple: we really do advertise one competitor while using the same advertisement to damage the reputation of another.

Let us look at how this kind of anti-advertising works in practice.

Competitor Reputation Attacks Through Negative Reviews

Suppose several drinking water suppliers operate in the market. Using negative online reviews, we will try to pit two competitors against each other.

For example, one water producer is based in Moscow and the other in Saint Petersburg.

Negative reviews begin to appear about the Saint Petersburg producer, saying that the company sells counterfeit products and poor-quality water, overcharges for its services and employs staff who are rude to customers.

At the same time, those reviews state that dissatisfied customers were forced to stop using that company and switch to the Moscow producer, which supposedly offers better-quality service.

In this way, reviews attacking one competitor also promote the other producer.

Naturally, reviews supposedly written by customers who do not exist attract the attention of management at the Saint Petersburg company. Seeing the Moscow producer promoted in almost every negative review, management begins to suspect it of organising the black PR campaign.

Then, after some time — a month, for example — similar negative reviews begin appearing about the Moscow producer. This time, the reviews praise the Saint Petersburg company.

As a result, the Moscow producer may interpret what is happening as its competitor’s response to the earlier information campaign.

As a result, both companies suspect each other of organising black PR and see the situation as an information war between them.

Negative Publicity About Competitors in News Media

The next stage brings the media into the conflict, taking the information war to a more serious level.

For example, a news site or specialist publication may carry an analytical article comparing drinking water producers operating in the market.

The material is presented as an independent expert study in which products from various manufacturers were supposedly tested blind, with water samples examined by an independent laboratory.

In the article, one producer — the Moscow company, for example — is presented as the best on the market. The article claims its water was the cleanest and of the highest quality.

Meanwhile, the Saint Petersburg producer’s water is supposedly found to contain impurities and chlorine, and signs that it may have come from a tap rather than an artesian source.

The remaining producers are discussed in almost neutral terms, without an overtly positive or negative assessment.

At the end of such an article, a notice in small print may indicate that it is advertising, naming a manager of either the Moscow or the Saint Petersburg company as the advertiser, depending on which producer was portrayed favourably.

This creates the impression that the article was commissioned and placed by one competitor to discredit the other.

As a result, the two companies are drawn into a conflict, interpreting such publications as actions against each other.

This is one of the simplest, most basic examples of anti-advertising. However, it clearly illustrates the general scheme for pitting two competing companies against each other.

Deceptive Advertising Posing as Genuine Promotion

But what if two competitors cannot be pushed into a conflict? For example, when there is effectively only one serious competitor, or the market is divided in such a way that any negative publicity would immediately raise suspicions about who commissioned it.

Such a situation is possible when the market is divided between two companies whose owners are relatives. In that case, an overt campaign against either company may be too obvious.

In precisely such situations, anti-advertising can be disguised as genuine advertising for the company in question.

The main feature is that the advertising itself is so aggressive or irritating that, instead of attracting customers, it creates negative associations among the intended audience.

The aim is to run what appears to be genuine advertising for the competitor, but in a form that drives away potential and existing customers instead of attracting them.

In practice, this takes a variety of forms.

Aggressive Outdoor Advertising in a Competitor’s Name

One example is aggressive outdoor advertising. For example, putting up advertising leaflets.

Leaflets are printed on self-adhesive paper and placed on cars, on the windows themselves, making them difficult to remove.

Naturally, this type of advertising annoys drivers. The leaflet obstructs their view and is often quite difficult to remove from the glass.

The driver sees which company the leaflet advertises and directs their complaints to that company, believing it organised the campaign.

This method works especially well against small local businesses: cafés, beauty salons and other businesses serving residents of a particular neighbourhood.

As a result, this aggressive advertising can trigger a wave of negativity among local residents, who begin to associate the inconvenience with the company being advertised.

Advertising Placed Where It Is Not Welcome

Another approach involves placing advertising where it is particularly unwelcome. For example, on apartment doors or other surfaces where advertising notices are not normally posted.

In one of our projects, the target was an adult products shop.

Advertising leaflets for the shop were prepared with images of sex toys, naked women and other provocative photographs.

These leaflets were put up in kindergartens and schools.

Naturally, the advertising provoked an intensely negative reaction from parents. A wave of complaints followed, and later there was even an attempt to smash the shop window.

So an advertisement that looked like an ordinary promotion of the shop’s products became a cause of serious public anger.

Aggressive Bulk Messaging and Advertising

Another form of aggressive anti-advertising involves bulk messaging. Such messages can reach people through letterboxes, phone numbers, email or messaging apps.

The advertising messages use psychological techniques intended to provoke irritation, offence or an openly negative response from recipients.

For example, in one mailing we used the following text:

“Hey, loser! Still haven’t been to the shop on Pyatnitskaya Street? Still walking around looking like a total reject? Stop looking like a broke nobody! Come in, and we’ll make a normal person out of you.”

Here, the insults were packaged as a kind of advertising slogan. However, most recipients found the wording offensive rather than amusing.

People complained about the advertising, blocked the senders and even went to the shop in person to voice their objections.

As a result, this anti-advertising created negative associations with the shop not only among potential buyers, but also among its regular customers.

People disliked being addressed in such an insulting way, and some later stopped shopping there.

Fake Discount Coupons and Gift Vouchers

Another form of discrediting and anti-advertising involves fake discount coupons and gift vouchers.

For example, gift coupons for products and services, or discount cards offering exceptionally large discounts and bonuses, are issued in the name of a particular shop or company.

These offers reach a broad audience. They may be electronic coupons sent to telephone numbers and email addresses, or paper letters placed in mailboxes around the neighborhood where the organization or shop is located.

When people receive a coupon offering a substantial discount or an attractive bonus, some decide to use it, particularly if they already shop with that company.

But when they arrive at the shop, they are disappointed.

The employees know nothing about these promotions and cannot provide the promised discount or gift. Naturally, the customer is turned away.

People see this as deception: the shop appears to have attracted customers with discounts and bonuses it never intended to provide.

The result is a wave of negative reactions that discourages customers from returning to the shop or business.

Staff explanations that the company has been set up and the coupons are fake do not always convince customers. They continue to think that they have simply been deceived.

Fabricated Interviews with Company Executives

Another online anti-advertising method involves fabricated interviews with a competitor’s representatives or executives.

In these interviews, the executive is portrayed as a selfish person focused exclusively on making money, deception and manipulation. An entirely negative image is created around the executive and the way they operate.

Even if the company offers high-quality services, its executive can be portrayed as an arrogant and unscrupulous capitalist who will do anything for profit.

One striking example is black PR directed at Herman Gref, in which the negative image of Sberbank’s chief also affected perceptions of Sberbank itself.

This method has proved especially effective against major, high-profile companies already familiar to a wide audience.

Since information about such organizations and their executives is of interest to many people, publications can attract significant attention and influence perceptions of the executive and the company.

Deceptive Promotion in Politics and Election Campaigns

This black PR method is frequently used in politics and election campaigns, especially when openly spreading negative information about an opponent could have undesirable consequences.

For example, if two politicians are competing for the position of mayor, a large-scale information campaign against either one may immediately cause the public to suspect the other candidate.

Therefore, in such situations, anti-advertising against competitors is used to distribute fabricated promises or other material in the candidate’s name that can provoke a negative reaction from voters.

Such materials may include leaflets, prize draws, fabricated interviews or a fake election programme filled with promises that are practically impossible to keep.

Campaign tactics that voters have long regarded as discredited may also be used.

An Example from an Election Campaign

For example, in one of our projects we used a method involving the distribution of food parcels.

We put together a food parcel containing a kilogram of buckwheat, a kilogram of rice, a packet of pasta and several tins of food. All the products were expired and of poor quality.

Each parcel included an advertising leaflet for our client’s opponent, presenting the food as a gift from that candidate’s election campaign.

These parcels were distributed among pensioners, people with disabilities and members of the core electoral audience who were thought likely to vote for that candidate.

Naturally, the expired, poor-quality food caused a wave of negative reactions among recipients.

First, the distribution evoked associations with the 1990s, when legislators tried to bribe their electorate in this way.

Second, the quality of the food itself outraged people, who saw the gift as a sign of disrespect.

A wave of discussion, negative comments and ridicule of the candidate followed.

Ultimately, he lost the election, although he had previously been regarded as the clear frontrunner.

Viral Negative Publicity: Memes and Online Campaigns

Another form of anti-advertising combines an advertising campaign with the subsequent spread of memes, allowing negative information to go viral.

How does it work?

Let us return to the politician in whose name the expired food parcels were distributed.

After distributing the parcels, we created memes about the candidate and his supposed gifts to voters and circulated them on social networks.

People then began sharing them on their own, creating new memes and joining in the ridicule of the candidate.

His subsequent attempts to defend himself only made the effect stronger.

When the candidate publicly stated that he had not distributed any food parcels and had been set up, it became another reason for people to mock him.

Memes began appearing on social networks with wording such as: “It wasn’t me — aliens planted it!” or “I’m too stingy even to buy buckwheat.”

Although our creative team produced the first memes, social media users later picked up the idea and began circulating their own jokes and images about the situation.

As a result, the information campaign spread further through the audience’s own activity.

When Negative Publicity Becomes a News Story

Anti-advertising can be used against commercial companies on the same principle.

For example, an advertising campaign in an aggressive or insulting style appears in the organization’s name. The advertising itself then becomes a news story for media publications.

News reports describe how the company tried to promote its products or services but, instead of attracting customers, provoked widespread dissatisfaction.

Anti-advertising therefore becomes the basis for further negative publicity online.

What makes this approach distinctive is that a negative reaction begins to develop not only among people who encountered the advertising directly, but also among those who learned about it through publications.

For example, a news story appears stating that an advertising campaign triggered outrage among customers and that some began abandoning the organization’s services en masse.

Other customers who previously knew nothing about the advertising read these stories and also begin to feel dissatisfied.

A kind of crowd effect takes hold: people see other customers reacting negatively to a company whose services they also use, and begin perceiving its activities differently.

Eventually, some of them may also stop using the organization’s products or services.

Conclusion

This form of black PR has proved effective in campaigns that rely on other people to act, pit several competitors against each other, divert attention from our own company or shift suspicion onto another market participant.

Anti-advertising is also used when a discrediting campaign cannot be launched openly, but the intention is to provoke a negative reaction among the competitor’s existing customers.

For example, a company may hold a leading market position, be highly respected and have an enormous customer base. Its regular buyers are satisfied with the quality of its products and services, trust the company and have no intention of switching to competitors.

Yet it is precisely in this situation that anti-advertising can become a turning point, after which even loyal customers start feeling dissatisfied and stop doing business with the company.

This method is suitable for almost any organization, from small local businesses to the largest market players.

Even a company with an impeccable, virtually spotless reputation can be targeted by anti-advertising that appears to come from the company itself.

Later, this advertising can become a news hook for spreading negative information in the media, on social networks and on other internet resources.

A company’s prominence, authority, product and service quality, loyal customer base and positive reputation therefore do not always protect it from this method of black PR.