What Is Black PR? Meaning, Methods and Examples

What Is Black PR (Dark PR)? Meaning, Methods and Reputational Impact

First, let us explain what we mean by black PR.

Many people associate black PR with something dirty and illegal. It is most often linked to politics, celebrities, public figures and major scandals. So when you say that black PR can be used not only against a politician or celebrity, but also against an ordinary person who is not in the public eye, a small company or a business competitor, many people are very surprised.

In fact, black PR is not always something bad or illegal.

In practice, black PR means creating a negative image of a person, company or political party. Discrediting and undermining a reputation are methods of achieving that objective. But it is not even so much the artificial creation of negativity as a way of making negative facts public.

Where these negative facts come from, how compromising material is gathered, which black PR methods are used and where the line lies between lawful distribution of information and dirty methods - that is a separate question.

For preventive measures, see our guide to protecting an organization from black PR.

Our Approach to Black PR: How We Solve Clients’ Problems

At our agency, we see black PR as more than simply creating and distributing negative information about a person, company or politician. Above all, it is a tool for solving specific problems, a way of confronting opponents and competitors that can use entirely different methods.

In practice, black PR can include information attacks, reputation campaigns, distribution of compromising material, journalistic investigations and many other areas of work.

And this is where the main difference between our agency and its competitors becomes clear.

When a client comes to us for black PR, we do not offer the standard, off-the-shelf services used by almost every PR agency. First, we try to understand exactly what problem the client wants to solve and which methods will actually help achieve the desired result.

Because people do not come to us for black PR. They come to us with problems that need to be solved.

And those problems can be very different.

For example, someone has a conflict with another person and needs help resolving it. And it is entirely possible that the methods we propose to solve that problem will have nothing to do with black PR at all.

In other words, we use the term as a broad label. Strictly speaking, that changes its meaning, because we do not offer black PR only in its narrow sense.

We offer a comprehensive solution to a problem, not just services for creating and distributing negative information.

Depending on the situation, we develop an individual strategy that may include many methods, approaches and areas of work. Some of them may indeed fall under black PR, while others belong to entirely different activities.

Every case is different.

Our main difference lies in this comprehensive approach. We do not limit ourselves to standard information attacks, posting negative reviews or placing compromising material in the media.

We offer a solution using every available method and, most often, unconventional and innovative approaches that most competing agencies simply cannot offer because of their limited range of services, specialists and capabilities.

In other words, for us black PR is not a standalone service, but one of the tools for achieving the client’s objective.

Black PR Methods in Politics, Business and Against Individuals

It is important to understand that black PR methods depend largely on who the work targets and exactly what problem needs to be solved. There are no universal solutions here, because each case uses entirely different approaches, tools and ways of influencing reputation.

For example, when a company is involved, its business reputation and relationships with customers, competitors and partners come to the fore. If the target of black PR is a particular person, the methods will depend on the circumstances of the personal or professional conflict. Political black PR, meanwhile, has characteristics that distinguish it from the other areas.

That is why all black PR methods and services can broadly be divided into three main areas:

This is where the approach changes completely. Methods that can be used against a business are by no means always suitable for work against an individual. In politics, on the other hand, several areas of black PR are often combined at once.

Political Black PR: Methods and Key Differences

When it comes to politics, most black PR methods have long been known, used repeatedly in practice and proven themselves. So there is often no point in going out of our way to invent something new when tried-and-tested ways of working already exist.

But political black PR has one important characteristic.

As a rule, black PR against politicians covers several areas at once - from discrediting the individual to information campaigns involving their business connections and political activities.

Why is that?

Because an official’s or elected representative’s activities are often not limited to politics alone. They may be a former businessperson, work with various companies, have business partners or receive support from commercial organizations.

That is why political black PR often combines several types of reputation campaign.

The first area is black PR against an individual.

Here, negative coverage is built directly around the official or elected representative as a person, their biography, professional activities, public actions and statements.

Their relatives, colleagues, business partners and other members of their inner circle may come into focus if their activities are connected with the events under consideration.

In other words, an information campaign around one politician can involve an entire circle of people connected with their personal and professional activities.

The second area is black PR against companies and organizations.

This concerns businesses with which the politician is directly connected: companies owned by them or their business partners, organizations providing them with financial support and other commercial structures.

Here, political black PR intersects with methods of business competition. Publications about alleged violations, conflicts of interest or questionable business connections can harm not only the politician’s own business reputation but also that of associated organizations.

The third area is political black PR itself.

This includes election information campaigns, political campaigning, media scandals, publication of compromising material, pranks and other methods of influencing opinion connected with political activity and the electoral process.

Unlike ordinary black PR against an individual or company, this also raises the issue of how the public perceives the politician, their reputation among voters and the influence of negative publications on the election campaign.

Thus, black PR in politics is one of the broadest and most comprehensive areas, where discrediting individuals, undermining organizations’ business reputations, journalistic investigations, distribution of compromising material and political information campaigns themselves all intersect.

That is precisely why work on political reputation can include almost every area of PR, information and analytical work available at our agency.

Black PR Against Competitors: Anti-Advertising and Market Competition

When it comes to competition, the approach is entirely different. First, we need to understand how the competitor’s business works, which market niche it operates in, where its customers come from and how it earns its revenue.

You will agree that the methods used against a large industrial enterprise and a small online shop will be entirely different. What works in agriculture may not work at all in the service sector.

That is why we do not immediately suggest posting negative reviews or commissioning media publications. First, we thoroughly study the competitor’s business, its characteristics, strengths, weaknesses and potential reputational risks, and only then determine which black PR methods actually make sense to use.

All our work against competitors is usually divided into five main stages:

  1. Strategy development.
  2. Studying the business and preparing materials.
  3. Anti-advertising and work on the competitor’s business reputation.
  4. Offline work.
  5. Legal work and submissions to regulatory bodies.

If specific violations are identified during the investigation, we can bring in legal support, prepare submissions to the relevant government bodies, work with media newsrooms and support further coverage of the results of official inspections.

In this way, information work can continue in the legal sphere.

And it is important to understand that we do not necessarily need to use all five areas at the same time.

We develop an individual strategy in every case. Sometimes a journalistic investigation and a few publications are enough to solve the problem. Other situations require comprehensive work involving specialists from entirely different fields.

Moreover, such a strategy may consist entirely of lawful methods and not involve any of the dirty black PR usually associated with this service.

We discuss competitor anti-advertising and the methods used in this work in greater detail in our article ‘Competitor Smear Tactics: Deceptive Advertising and Negative Publicity’.

Black PR Against Individuals: Personal and Professional Reputation

When the work targets an individual, a particular person, there are no standard methods. Discrediting a person in such situations depends on the circumstances of the particular conflict.

In other words, every case is different.

A specific solution is always developed for each individual case, depending on what the client wants.

If someone simply wants to damage, for example, the business reputation of an executive, a boss or a subordinate - anything connected with work - that involves one set of services and methods. In essence, this is undermining business reputation and professional image.

But if it concerns something unique, unrelated to work and connected instead with the person’s personal activities, private life or particular aspects of their life, there is practically no limit to the imagination.

Here we use our creativity and, as a rule, take an unconventional approach to achieving the objective.


Black PR Services: What Sets Our Agency Apart

Why Unsupported Black PR Claims Often Fail

Why do we say that black PR does not always mean illegal methods? Because obtaining and distributing negative information can be done in entirely lawful ways, especially when it concerns real facts that can be supported by documents and evidence.

This is precisely where a PR agency’s experience, professional capabilities and approach to its work matter.

And this is one of our main differences from competitors.

As a rule, small advertising and PR agencies offering black PR services consist of only a few people. Most often, this means a copywriter and a manager who can write almost any text and arrange for it to be placed in some low-grade media outlet, Telegram channel or social network.

And they already consider themselves black PR gurus because they can make up any kind of defamatory claim, write a few negative articles, post negative reviews and spread it all online.

But the problem is that the quality of this work is often extremely low.

Writing defamatory claims is easy. It is much harder to make people believe negative information and ensure that it actually harms a business reputation.

After all, negative publications with no supporting evidence are fairly easy to challenge. Such materials may be removed following ordinary complaints, pre-litigation demands or a court decision.

And even if anti-advertising and the distribution of compromising material initially produce some result, that effect may be very short-lived.

Why?

Because people do not always believe everything they read online.

Even if negative information about a person or company reaches a potential customer, partner or acquaintance, their first step may be to look at the evidence, which simply will not be there. They may then look at the site where it was published and realize it is some low-grade website that is not particularly trustworthy.

Most importantly, these sites often have a fairly small audience. So even mass publication of negative articles and reviews does not guarantee that the information will actually reach the intended audience.

This creates another problem that many black PR agencies somehow forget.

Poor-quality black PR can not only fail to damage a reputation, but actually increase trust in the person or company it targets.

After some time, the target of a reputational attack may refute the accusations, have the defamatory content removed and publicly prove that they had nothing to do with what they were accused of.

And then all that black PR turns to their advantage.

The person becomes even more widely discussed, receives additional public attention, vindicates themselves and thereby earns greater trust.

In practice, instead of discrediting a person or undermining a company’s business reputation, the result is the exact opposite - free advertising.

People may reach a perfectly logical conclusion: if so many bad things are being written about someone but nothing can be proved, that person must really be getting in someone’s way. And perhaps this is just an attempt by worse competitors or rivals to drive them out of the market.

So instead of eliminating a competitor, you have done their advertising for them.

Comprehensive Reputation Campaigns Beyond Negative Publicity

In our work, however, creating and spreading negativity is effectively just one area within a huge, comprehensive black PR campaign.

What does that mean for us?

It means we do not stop at making up defamatory claims and putting them in writing, because that is very easy.

We look for supporting evidence ourselves. This involves finding information, checking facts and analyzing documents and sources.

Our agency’s capabilities allow us, first of all, to obtain data from restricted databases that only investigators can access.

We actively cooperate with both current and former employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.

We involve private detectives, lawyers and our people in investigative bodies to obtain all kinds of information: dossiers, restricted tax data, information on offenses, property and border crossings.

Everything the state and law enforcement know about you.

We can freely obtain all this information.

And then, with this information in hand, we can develop a better strategy than companies that simply invent things out of thin air.

Finding information and creating supporting evidence

The second difference is creating supporting evidence.

In other words, apart from obtaining information, we can create supporting evidence.

By creating supporting evidence, we mean that we have enough highly specialized professionals to produce any video, photograph or extract from a document. In our understanding, black PR here is not limited to writing a text.

We can even register legal entities and create websites and social media groups.

We work with a huge number of review websites, media outlets and archives.

And when creating supporting evidence, we do not limit ourselves to online publications.

We can carry out offline work.

We bring in people in different cities to do the work we need.

For example, they might conduct surveys, visit a location, take photographs or shoot video.

This is precisely where we begin doing what most competing agencies simply cannot offer.

An example of a journalistic investigation: inspecting an elected representative’s factory

A striking example was a project concerning a factory owned by an elected representative that was illegally discharging waste.

We first carried out a journalistic investigation, during which we contacted former employees of the factory, spoke to them and interviewed them.

We paid them for providing the contact details of current employees.

We spoke to current employees and paid them to leak information about the actual location of the pipe - the illegal pipe through which waste was being discharged into the sewer.

We brought in people who went to the location, dug up the pipe and documented everything in full.

We then had supporting evidence that even those who had inspected the factory site did not have.

This is an example of thorough work: rather than limiting ourselves to what someone has written online, we conduct our own investigation and obtain information directly on the ground.

Journalistic investigations and offline work

If we do not find any negative aspects that we can use in the work, we can conduct an additional journalistic investigation using resources unavailable to competing companies. Field investigations, interviews and work with primary sources become important here.

Because most agencies currently offering black PR are, in fact, information agencies.

They are used to working online, writing articles and distributing them.

But they do no fieldwork at all. Journalistic investigations in this format require working with people and primary materials.

Our capabilities are considerably broader.

Creating video reviews, video reports, news stories and compromising material

Another advantage is our ability to produce our own photos and videos.

We have well-developed photo and video editing departments, two in-house newsrooms producing video stories, our own television studio and professional editors.

That is why we can independently film and produce video reviews, video reports, journalistic investigations and news videos.

But it is important to understand another feature of black PR.

Compromising material does not necessarily have to be found. Compromising material can be created.

Moreover, creating compromising material does not always require actual negative episodes in a person’s biography or a company’s activities.

Dirty black PR also involves harsher methods: staged photographs, staged video stories, photo manipulation and other ways of fabricating compromising materials.

A striking example is our case involving the creation of compromising material in a sauna.

This is where we move from ordinary journalistic investigations, information gathering and spreading negativity to an entirely different area - dirty black PR methods in which compromising material is not found but artificially created from scratch. And our agency is a leader in this.


Dirty Black PR Methods: Reputation Attacks and Their Consequences

Now the main question: when does black PR involve dirty methods?

Here, the end justifies the means.

In fact, in our work we most often offer clients a fairly broad set of means and methods that can help solve the problem.

Most often, we try to use more lawful, cleaner methods precisely to leave the opponent no chance of resisting.

Because the more dirty methods you use, the greater the chance that the other side will start fighting back and succeed.

Reputational risks: why should the target not become a victim?

It is very important not to turn the target of your work into a victim.

They should be the monster instead.

The objective of the work is to create the image of such a monster, turn the public against them and turn the audience groups targeted by this black PR against them.

Whether these are their customers, friends, acquaintances or the electorate - their voters.

But it is important not to cross the line and turn the person into a victim - someone people start to sympathize with.

Because when you sling mud at someone, there is always a certain line.

Up to that line, people build up negative feelings and direct them at the target of black PR.

But once you cross that line, they simply start feeling sorry for them.

Adjusting the strategy and monitoring public response

It is important to understand that when a black PR strategy is developed, it is not always final.

During the work, audience reactions and the consequences of the actions taken are always analyzed. This monitoring of public response helps take reputational risks into account.

Decisions are then made according to that response: whether to make the campaign harsher to achieve the effect or, on the contrary, to soften it.

When lawful, standard methods no longer work - for example, when you distribute compromising material but it is either quickly removed or does not produce the required result - harsher forms of black PR are added to the information campaign. These are not entirely lawful and are quite dirty from a moral point of view.

But in a particular case, they may prove more effective.

What exactly does this mean?

Several types can be distinguished here too.


Kompromat: Creating and Leaking Compromising Material — How We Fabricate Photos, Videos and Reviews

Now let us turn to the harsher, dirtier black PR methods that we can use in our work.

The first area is creating compromising material from scratch.

Here we are talking about straightforward fabrication. When we do not find real negative facts, we can artificially create compromising materials that outwardly look like genuine evidence.

This can involve staged photographs, edited videos, invented reviews and even entire pseudo-journalistic investigations.

In practice, we create an artificial evidence base, giving the impression that the person or company really committed the acts they are accused of.

And it is important to understand that creating such compromising material does not require any real negative episodes involving the target of our work.

To make this clearer, I will give a few examples of these black PR methods.

Example No. 1. Compromising material on a groom before his wedding

The task is to discredit a groom before his wedding, but the man has done nothing wrong and is not cheating.

We rent the sauna where the bachelor party takes place and install hidden surveillance cameras.

The bachelor party then proceeds as usual, without women. The groom has done nothing wrong.

But the following day, we bring an actor who looks very much like the groom to the sauna and film him from behind with prostitutes or a naked woman, hugging and kissing.

A standard photomontage is then created, and these photographs are presented as real.

It is quite difficult to spot the fake because the photographs are taken from behind, from a fairly long distance, with hidden cameras and are of poor quality.

Using photo manipulation, real frames from the bachelor party showing the groom’s friends are added to the photographs with the actor. Women also appear in the video.

In this way, compromising material on the groom is artificially created.

Or on an elected representative.

This method is very popular in PR campaigns against officials, where photographs and videos of this kind are created for use against specific people even when they have no connection with prostitutes - in other words, without any actual infidelity.

This is creating compromising material from scratch. That is the meaning of the request to ‘create compromising material’ when there are no initial negative facts.

This is a striking example of fieldwork.

It is a dirty method most often used in politics or against individuals.

Example No. 2. Discrediting companies through reviews and pseudo-investigations

The second example is when compromising material needs to be created about a company or organization.

An even simpler method here is writing negative reviews supposedly from former or current employees.

This is the simplest thing that most agencies currently offer and work with.

A slightly more complex method is publishing a pseudo-journalistic investigation in the media, attempting to pass invented facts off as genuine evidence. In essence, this is discrediting an organization through media and negative publications.

An even more complex method is video reviews.

For example, when negative reviews of a product or service are needed, specialized websites are used to recruit people who criticize the product or a company on video while presenting themselves as its customers.

As a rule, these video reviews are trusted more because the person’s face is visible and everyone thinks they really are a customer of the company.

Or people posing as victims are recruited to spread information on social media about how they became victims of the company, claiming that it is fraudulent.

In practice, this means using people posing as customers.

And this remains one of the most common and simplest dirty black PR methods used against companies.

Example No. 3. Creating customer complaints: a reputational attack on a company

There is an even more sophisticated way of working against companies, one that requires some preparation. This is an example of black PR extending beyond ordinary publications.

It involves creating real complaints and genuine dissatisfaction among the company’s real customers.

How does it all work, and why is preparation needed?

First, the company’s online resources are taken over - whether its website, group or a page listing its products and services.

Phone numbers and contact forms are replaced.

The PR practitioner’s main task in this case is to attract a real customer of the company but redirect them to fake sites or pages.

The PR agency’s employee can then work with a real customer of the company.

From there, the rest is straightforward.

The customer is given payment details - the company’s real payment details - and makes a payment using them.

But naturally, no services are provided, because the company knows nothing about this customer.

The company also has little idea where the money came from or what it is for.

And the customer who transferred the money receives no service.

Now we have a genuinely dissatisfied customer who really is ready to complain, go to law enforcement or Rospotrebnadzor, write negative reviews and confirm the purchase.

This creates genuine supporting evidence, because the person has a genuine bank statement showing that they paid for services using those payment details.

They have all the receipts, and they really did not receive the service.

This is, essentially, a method of setting the company up.

The method is used just as successfully against ordinary individuals who provide services - manicurists, organizers of training courses on Instagram, bloggers and others.

Promotions are launched in their names, or services are offered that they do not actually provide.

Payments are accepted using their real payment details.

And in practice, there is almost no way to guard against this.

The company cannot protect itself because it does not even know what is happening.

The only thing it can do is promptly refund customers while trying to resolve the issue.

But, as they say, it still leaves a bad taste.

Even after receiving a refund, the person may already have left reviews or filed complaints.

The black PR practitioner’s job is to promptly spread the word everywhere that the company is deceiving people and that people are filing complaints against it.

That is it.

That is one of the dirty methods of black PR.


Black PR and disruption of a company’s operations: DDoS attacks and hacking

DDoS attacks, website hacking and disruption of work processes

Dirty black PR methods can also include various kinds of work aimed at disrupting a company’s normal operations.

For example, if a company depends on its website, DDoS attacks and hacking attacks against the website are used.

Here is another example from our work.

Removing compromising material: a conflict with review websites and removal of negative content

A client came to us with a problem involving negative news stories and reviews about them.

A number of review websites had started publishing negative articles about the client and demanding money to remove them. This is how some website owners try to make money from compromising material and its removal.

The sums demanded were so astronomical that paying made no sense.

And when we tried paying to remove information from one website, it immediately started being copied onto other sites. Removing the compromising material this way proved unsuccessful.

In this way, they tried to turn the client into a cash cow.

Since the people on the other side were unreasonable, trying to negotiate or find a compromise was pointless.

So the decision was made to act against them using equally dirty methods.

First, we tried to resolve the issue with the help of law enforcement.

But because the website owners were in another, hostile country, they felt they could act with impunity.

We therefore brought in hackers who hacked their websites every day and posted prohibited information on them.

Complaints about these websites were then sent to their hosting providers, Roskomnadzor and the FSB.

Ultimately, our efforts led the FSB to confiscate those domains and completely shut down the websites publishing the negative information.

In this way, we solved the client’s problem using methods that were not entirely lawful but were highly effective: hacking attacks against websites.


Black PR in politics: dirty methods and fake news videos

Dirty methods are used even more often in politics.

And they are actually even harsher.

Disrupting an election debate using a fake news report

One of the harshest examples of dirty black PR is the story of disrupting an election debate between two candidates for mayor.

Before a decisive election, we were tasked with disrupting a debate in which two competing politicians were due to take part.

In this scenario, we used a fairly cruel method - a fabricated news video supposedly just broadcast by a well-known national television channel.

The report said that the daughter of one of the candidates had been admitted to intensive care a few hours earlier and had died from a drug overdose.

Moreover, the video claimed that the young woman had repeatedly undergone treatment in rehabilitation centers, had taken antidepressants, and that suicide was one of the theories concerning her death. Supposedly, she had deliberately taken a large quantity of drugs and medication, washing it all down with alcohol.

We ensured that the opponent saw the recording shortly before the debate began. Everything looked as though the tragic news had just been reported on national television.

For a man already of quite advanced age, news of the death of his own daughter was a profound shock.

He did not even suspect that the video was fake and that his daughter was actually alive and well.

As a result, the candidate could not participate in the debate. Only several hours later, when he managed to reach his daughter by phone, did he realize that he had been the victim of a cruel deception.

But by then, the debate had already been disrupted.

This is one example of how far dirty black PR methods can go. This is no longer simply about spreading compromising material or undermining a reputation, but about deliberately exerting psychological pressure on a person.


Our Agency’s Approach to Moral and Legal Limits

This raises a logical question: which black PR methods can our agency use, and which are ruled out by certain moral and legal standards?

The agency as a tool: the hammer analogy

An analogy helps explain this.

In practice, our agency is a tool.

How to use it is for the client to decide.

And all responsibility for using any particular method lies directly with the client.

To make this clearer, consider a hammer.

A hammer is a tool.

But one person may use a hammer to drive nails, while another may use it to kill someone.

In both cases, the hammer is a tool.

But the hammer is not responsible for the actions of the person holding it.

The same applies to our agency.

We can implement various options and methods, provide the client with materials, create supporting evidence, create compromising material on a person and do everything to achieve the objective.

But the decision to use particular methods and tools lies directly with the client.

Lawful methods and clients’ individual decisions

As a rule, we try to persuade the client to use lawful methods. Black PR itself does not mean that illegal methods must be used.

Methods that are difficult to refute and that are effective.

But, as the saying goes, the customer is always right, and we do try to accommodate the client to some extent.

And if the client needs something more specific, we can provide it, as long as it stays within the law and does not create risks for our employees or our reputation.