Black PR against companies is one of the most widespread tactics in business competition.
For the preventive perspective, read about protecting a business from black PR before an information attack starts.
Any self-respecting marketer understands perfectly well that offering quality services, inexpensive products and advertising a business is not enough to take a leading position in a highly competitive market.
That is why, in highly competitive sectors, one of the most effective methods of promoting your services is eliminating competitors from the market. After all, when there are fewer competitors, the market can be divided into spheres of influence.
Take, for example, a small town with just two providers of a particular service. Let us say two companies deliver drinking water to organizations.
Their prices are approximately the same, and so is the quality of their product. In other words, practically identical drinking water at the same price. Delivery to offices is also free or charged at the same rates.
In practice, customers see little difference between them.
In this situation, you can spend money on advertising endlessly, trying to prove that you are better. But advertising costs will be quite high, and you will have to keep spending: both sides will be running advertising campaigns.
But if one market participant uses black PR against the other, they will simply win. Because they can launch a PR campaign spreading information that their competitor, in this case a water supplier, simply fills the bottles with tap water, misses delivery deadlines, is rude, insults or deceives customers, or fails to meet its obligations.
And that is it.
People who see this information will naturally not go to the competitor. They will go to the other market participant, who will effectively become a monopolist.
Thus, by launching a black PR campaign against a competitor just once, with a fairly small budget, you can become a leader and monopolist in your field.
This approach is also much cheaper than constantly spending money on advertising.
This brings us to how black PR against an organization is carried out, which methods of attacking competitors are most effective, which are inexpensive, and which require specialized agencies with extensive capabilities.
Online Smear Campaigns Against Businesses: Reviews, Media and Social Networks
Negative and Fake Reviews Used in Business Smear Campaigns
Negative Reviews Posing as Customer Feedback
The simplest and most widespread method of black PR against an organization is posting negative reviews.
As a rule, when people want to find out whether an organization is good or not, they look for reviews about it.
Reviews can be posted on Google Maps and Yandex Maps (a regional mapping and review service), where they can be viewed directly in the organization’s listing. This is the simplest option.
Or on specialized review sites that publish customer and employee reviews, such as the regional platforms Otzovik, Flamp and others.
As a rule, people place considerable trust in reviews because reviews are written by customers.
One way of conducting black PR against an organization is to post reviews in a customer’s name.
This is one of the simplest and most effective methods. It is suitable for black PR against any organization, small or large.
Negative Reviews Posing as Employee Feedback
This method is also quite effective because there are far more employer review sites than customer review sites.
Employer reviews are also often indexed much better.
There are many specialized employer review sites: AntiJob, NakhJob, DreamJob and Pravda Sotrudnikov. They appear prominently in searches for “reviews of” followed by the organization’s name.
Therefore, when running a black PR campaign, posting reviews in the names of both former and current employees should not be ignored.
For example, former employees can say in reviews that they left the company because it sets up its employees, forces them to provide poor-quality services to customers or to deceive customers.
For each line of business, specific accusations of dishonest dealings with customers can be devised for purported former employees to make against the company.
If the company sells products, such reviews may state that these products are of low quality, do not justify their market price, or are outright counterfeits.
They can also describe how, when a customer realizes this and starts complaining or tries to return the product, the employee is left alone with the problem. And it is the employee who is blamed, not the management.
Fabricated shortages are charged to the employee in an attempt to cover losses from returned or poor-quality products.
Or, if the company provides services, the employee is also blamed for poor service, even though the management itself ordered the services to be provided in that way.
In other words, negative reviews in employees’ names spread purported insider information about how customers are deceived or what poor-quality products the company sells.
And most often, the negative impact of employee reviews is greater than that of customer reviews.
Because a company can say that it has never had such a customer and that it is all defamation. But when its former employees complain, the information is perceived as truthful and coming from insiders.
Reputation Attacks on Employees and Executives
Another effective way to discredit an organization is to smear its employees and executives.
When we have information about a company’s employees, we can start black PR directly against those employees. Because they are part of the company, and their reputation affects the reputation of the organization itself.
Most often, the same methods are used.
These are reviews, except that the negative reviews give the full names of specific employees, portraying them as fraudsters who allegedly set customers up, organize corrupt and fraudulent schemes, demand kickbacks and behave rudely towards customers.
Such reviews are usually trusted more because they name specific people, real company employees, rather than faceless authors about whom nothing is known.
Fake Customer Video Reviews About Companies
Another method of black PR against an organization is distributing negative video reviews in customers’ names.
It is important to distinguish between two types here.
The first is negative video reviews of service companies.
If a company provides services, a video review is recorded by someone posing as a customer, saying that the services were of poor quality and that the company took the money but did not provide the services paid for.
Or an entire story is created about how the company did a poor job, then deceived the customer, took the money, made threats after negative reviews were posted, and its lawyers pressured the customer and threatened them in every possible way.
These video reviews are recorded by specially hired people, actors, after which the videos are posted on social networks and used as supporting evidence for media publications.
The second is negative video reviews of the company’s products.
If a company sells products, one method is to have our people make video reviews of those products.
Defects are artificially introduced into the product, or an expired product is used, a product is allowed to pass its expiry date, or a false expiry date in the past is applied.
In our experience, there was a case where we needed to discredit a grocery store’s operations.
So our employees deliberately obtained a batch of expired products, took them into the store and placed them on the shelves.
Then they simply made a video showing a supposedly random person entering the supermarket, taking products from its shelves and showing that the products had expired long ago but were still on the supermarket’s shelves.
These video reviews were then distributed online.
Media Smear Campaigns Against Businesses
The next method of black PR against a company is one of the most effective because it appears credible.
It involves discrediting a company through negative information published about it in the media.
These may be news websites, news groups on social networks, print publications, or staged news video reports imitating well-known television channels.
We will now look at each of these methods separately.
Publishing Negative Stories About Companies in the Media
The first method is publishing negative information about a company in the media.
In our experience, this is one of the most effective methods because people are accustomed to trusting news reports.
And when a company becomes involved in a scandal covered by the media, people believe the reports, and the company’s reputation is severely damaged.
This is a specialized method: many companies offering black PR today simply cannot afford it. They have no access to editorial offices and do not operate in this price range.
That is why this method is offered only by established agencies that have worked in the field for a long time and have direct access to news websites and media editorial offices.
The essence of the method is to invent a scandal around the target of the black PR, that is, the organization, and news about it is published in various media outlets.
Here, it is important to understand the project’s reach and goals.
Placement may be regional, with news published on websites and in media outlets of a particular region. For example, in news communities, on news sites and on city forums in a specific city.
Or, when the budget allows and the company is large, it is taken to the federal level. Major federal media and general news websites covering events across the country become involved.
An accusation of fraud can serve as an example.
News is spread that a defrauded customer of a certain company has gone to court or staged a one-person picket demanding their money back.
Or news stories are circulated stating that the prosecutor’s office or Investigative Committee is investigating the company for fraud, failure to pay taxes, counterfeiting and other matters.
Here, the imagination has no limits.
Another method is publishing information in the media that the company has ceased operations, its activities have been declared illegal, or the products it sells are dangerous or counterfeit.
As mentioned above, when working on a particular company, its field of activity and the services or products it offers are studied in detail.
Negative factors that could put off its customers are identified specifically for the black PR target. This is what the media publications emphasize.
It is also important to understand that, when preparing media publications, we create supporting evidence as well.
Because, as a rule, every company has its own lawyers who may try to challenge these publications and file defamation lawsuits.
This is where a professional approach matters: creating supporting evidence and a scheme under which the company’s defenders cannot promptly remove negative media coverage about it.
Fabricated News Video Reports
The next black PR method is creating and distributing news video reports that copy the style of a well-known television channel.
What does that mean?
For example, the company operates nationwide, and we produce a video report that fully copies the style of Channel One news or the Vesti program.
A script is prepared, a presenter is hired, and a virtual studio is created in the style of a well-known news program.
The presenter reports that the company has become the subject of a scandal or a criminal case, and that its schemes or crimes are national in scope.
Or it is reported that the company’s management has been arrested and that its executives are foreign agents, have siphoned off money and have supported another country’s military.
Or footage appears that is presented as law enforcement searches at the company’s office.
Such a video report is almost impossible to distinguish from a real news report.
The video is distributed on social networks as a recording of television news that supposedly aired on a certain date.
News stories citing this video report are then distributed in the media.
In other words, in practice, the video report itself becomes a news hook.
Checking the authenticity of such a video report is rather difficult: an inquiry has to be sent to the television channel to establish whether the program aired, and often even its alleged broadcast time is unknown.
While the company tries to establish all of this, time passes and its reputation suffers severely.
News video reports are also trusted more because nobody in the audience even suspects that a news video can be faked and that nothing of the sort was actually shown on television.
As a rule, news video reports provoke an enormous public response.
Therefore, when such a report is posted in social media groups, it is usually viewed by more people than a regular text-based news article.
Moderators of news groups and media outlets are also quite skeptical of written news and require confirmation of every legally contentious point. Because a text can say anything and contain any defamatory claims.
But when they see a news video supposedly recorded from television, they cannot independently verify its authenticity and therefore often do not consider that it might be fake.
That is why it is almost always accepted for publication.
And this method is one of the most devastating to a reputation and one of the most effective, although it is also among the most expensive.
Social Media Reputation Attacks Against Businesses
The next black PR method is black PR against an organization on social networks.
This method involves engaging a large and fairly targeted audience and generating a public response around a scandal-real or artificially created-involving the company.
In practice, any negative story surrounding even the smallest company can be turned into an event that causes a stir among people who have no connection to the company and have never heard of it.
For example, take the same example of a water delivery company or producer in a small town.
In such towns, everyone effectively knows one another, while the social media audience is, first, quite young and, second, rather limited.
But this can be used as an advantage because, as a rule, they are all concentrated in the same places: their town’s community page and news groups dedicated to events in that town.
If information is posted in these communities, it quickly spreads through reposts and generates a response through comments. Therefore, this method can be used against almost any company, regardless of its reach.
The larger the city and the company, the greater the public response that can be created.
For example, information can be spread that the town has had an outbreak of dysentery or cholera and that, as it turned out, it was caused by water delivered or produced by the company.
Such news will already provoke a response from people who bought that water or knew anything about the company.
But to broaden the audience and provoke even greater outrage and public response, a detail can be added that an infant died as a result of the epidemic or outbreak, after which the mother slit her wrists.
This technique brings in an additional, sympathetic audience and generates hatred towards the company.
One subtype of this kind of campaign is setting a negative tone under social media posts.
A specially created network of bot accounts is used to post comments under each news item. The texts of these comments are written from the outset to make people want to join the discussion.
For example, comments from anyone involved in the discussion can be answered rudely in the names of company employees, provoking even greater outrage.
Or a statement can be issued in the company’s name that discredits it even further.
There is a psychological technique whereby comments from several people are added, using a bot network, under new posts that have no comments yet, thereby encouraging others to respond to them.
This immediately sets the tone of the discussion and draws more people into the topic.
Calls to boycott the company or file complaints against it are also added, or further information is included about people having previously suffered poisoning from its products without this being made public.
This black PR method is very effective because it generates a public response. With the right approach, it is possible to create a natural, genuine wave of negativity among real people who do not even suspect they have become mere puppets in someone else’s game.
Fake Customer Complaints on Legal Advice Forums
The next black PR method is posting messages purportedly from former customers on legal forums, consultation websites and question-and-answer platforms.
This is one method of creating evidence that defrauded customers exist.
A list of possible ways the company could deceive customers in its field is developed for each company. These methods are then presented as actions that have already taken place.
For example, if the company works in services, a question is posted in a customer’s name on specialized legal forums, describing the situation: this company deceived me, provided services that did not match our agreement or failed to meet its obligations.
“Could you please tell me what I can do, how I can get help, and how I can protect myself legally?”
Another method is for a person to complain to lawyers and ask for legal help, supposedly after threats from the company.
For example, someone posted a negative review about the company, but its security service first removed the review through complaints, or tracked the customer down and used force to make them delete it.
The police refused to accept the report, and the company’s representatives keep making threats. How can one obtain legal protection against this?
This method is quite effective at creating a negative image around a company when negative reviews cannot be posted.
For example, if the company quickly disputes negative reviews, removes them, or has simply paid specialized platforms to moderate and delete negative reviews about it.
In that case, these questions on legal forums are effectively reviews, generating negative publicity about the company and serving as evidence that it is fraudulent or threatens its customers.
And the absence of negative reviews is presented as proof that the company intimidates everyone who tries to post one.
Offline Reputation Attacks Against Businesses
One of the most advanced and effective methods our company offers is offline black PR against an organization.
This is a fairly broad range of services that our employees individually plan, develop and carry out for major projects and when driving competitors out of the market.
This method can include various forms of work.
It is practically impossible to describe all of them, so we will focus on some of the simplest and most common offline methods used against organizations.
Work Involving Pseudo-Customers
One method is working with fake customers.
A stream of inquiries from fake customers is organized to burden the company with extra work and prevent it from fully processing new customer requests.
In other words, a large group of people contacts the company to request its services.
An important point: this method is suitable for companies that offer services or sell products and use cashless payments.
As mentioned above, a stream of inquiries is organized from supposed customers who try to draw things out as much as possible.
Each fake customer tries to occupy as much of the manager’s time as possible. They ask for additional information, mention errors and problems, and keep in constant contact, preventing the manager from turning to real customers.
In other words, the goal of this black PR method is to make the target company’s employees spend as much time as possible on fake customers.
Another goal is to obtain additional information about the company that can later be used as supporting evidence when posting negative reviews or publishing articles in the media.
What does that mean?
For example, obtaining the company’s bank account details, contract texts, employees’ and executives’ names, and its complete catalogue of products or services, on which future reviews or media articles will be based.
The result is that the company’s employees spend almost all their time on people who will ultimately never become its customers, and cannot handle genuine requests from customers who want to use its services or buy its products.
Creating Negative Attention Outside the Company’s Office
The next offline method is creating a negative atmosphere around the company’s office.
Its purpose is essentially to create a news hook for subsequent media and social network publications.
What does that mean?
Several approaches should be distinguished here.
Putting up and handing out leaflets
One approach is putting up and handing out leaflets in the area where the company’s office is located or in the areas where its customers are based.
The idea is that the leaflets may contain negative information about the company. For example, information that it is fraudulent, with links to relevant resources containing negative information about it.
Or the leaflets are distributed as advertising on the company’s behalf.
But the leaflets are distributed aggressively.
For example, the leaflets contain real advertising for the company, but they are glued to cars. They are not merely placed there but glued to the windshield in a way that makes them impossible to peel off.
Or they are stuck in building entrances in highly inconvenient places, cover up other information, or are stuffed in enormous piles into mailboxes.
In other words, the leaflets are placed so aggressively that people immediately develop a negative reaction towards the company.
The second way of creating negativity around a company is to use false company contact details in advertising leaflets.
A copy of its website is made and entirely different telephone numbers are given. Customers who call or use any of the contacts on the leaflet are handled by a specially created call center or website that presents itself as belonging to the company.
Even the company’s payment details will be provided, but no services will be delivered and no products sold.
As a result, money will arrive in the company’s accounts from customers it knows nothing about. Customers will transfer money without being able to contact a real company representative and without receiving the services or products they paid for.
This creates the appearance of fraud by the company and generates a real flow of complaints against it from real people to law enforcement and regulatory authorities.
Or simply encourage real people to post negative reviews based on their real experience.
In other words, this is one way of setting a company up.
Organizing fake pickets and fake protests
Another offline black PR method is organizing fake pickets and fake protests outside the company’s office.
This method is used to create a news hook for subsequent publications in the media and on social networks, as well as to produce footage for news video reports.
The method consists of selecting groups of people who gather outside the office on a day off, early in the morning or late in the evening, when it is closed.
They quickly unfold signs saying that the company is fraudulent, “Give us our money back,” and calling on law enforcement to investigate the company, carry out inspections, shut it down and so on.
A photographer quickly takes pictures of these people with the office in the background. The people then fold up all the signs and leave.
This attracts little attention from passers-by, but provides photographs of a fake picket outside the company’s office and footage for later video reports and publications on social media and in the press.
News is then spread in the media that defrauded customers are already organizing rallies and pickets outside the company’s office, and this becomes evidence that the company is fraudulent.
An example from our practice
In our practice, there was a case where we needed to disrupt a government contract at a leather factory that had received an order to manufacture leather footwear-combat boots for the Russian army.
But after receiving the order, the factory faced a staff shortage and management launched a recruitment drive to find new employees. Hiring enough workers to fulfill the order was very important to them.
We organized just such a fake picket outside the factory, supposedly by employees demanding several months of unpaid wages and the correction of safety violations.
The signs stated that workers suffered many occupational injuries. They also said that the factory discharged untreated waste into the city’s sewer system.
A staged interview was also filmed on a day off: a journalist spoke to fake workers outside the factory while they described the violations.
A video report was then edited and circulated through local media, causing people to distrust the factory and discouraging them from applying for jobs there.
As a result, the factory could not recruit enough employees and failed to fulfill the government contract.
Legal and Regulatory Pressure on Companies
When major market players are involved, as the saying goes, all is fair in war.
And to burden the company’s employees with additional work that consumes its time and resources, lawful methods are also used- legal ways of exerting pressure on a company.
These methods include various complaints to inspection authorities, complaints against the company’s online resources, complaints to search engines and complaints in the names of defrauded customers.
As a rule, a legal basis is also created for each complaint. The complaint requires the company to respond, involve its lawyers and seek legal assistance.
Various complaints against a company can also become an excellent news hook for further media stories about inspections and complaints against it, thereby harming its business reputation.
Complaints against the company’s website through hosting providers, registrars and search engines
The first method of legal pressure on a company is filing complaints against its website through hosting providers and domain name registrars.
In this case, complaints are submitted about copyright infringement, suspected fraud and other violations.
Complaints are also sent to search engines regarding suspected copyright infringement, phishing and various legal violations on the company’s website.
The purpose of this method is to lower the company website’s search rankings, as well as to create additional problems that the company will be forced to spend time and resources resolving.
Complaints in the names of dissatisfied customers and employees
One method is finding dissatisfied employees and customers, as well as real facts about the company’s activities. This makes it possible to find people willing to file a complaint against it.
As a rule, these people ask for money in return.
If no such people can be found, fake customers are recruited who are willing, in exchange for payment, to write complaints against the company and thereby force law enforcement to carry out various inspections.
Or these complaints are used as a means of subsequently accusing the company of fraud, poor-quality services or the sale of poor-quality products.
A media outlet’s appeal to the prosecutor’s office and the Investigative Committee
The next method is one we use quite often in practice and consider one of the most effective: a complaint to the prosecutor’s office on behalf of a particular media outlet’s editorial office.
How does it work?
First, an investigative report is written, describing instances of fraud, corrupt schemes and unlawful actions by the company. Specific facts, either discovered or artificially created, are presented, and a media investigation is published on that basis.
The editorial office that published the investigation then sends a request to the prosecutor’s office and the Investigative Committee, asking them to investigate and verify every alleged legal violation described in its own investigation.
A list of materials and supporting evidence are attached to the request. Everything is sent to the prosecutor’s office and the Investigative Committee both in writing by mail and through online reception portals.
After that, under the procedure described, the prosecutor’s office and the Investigative Committee must accept the request for processing within 30 days.
Once the request has been accepted for processing, a reply arrives stating that the request has been registered under a particular number.
This already provides a news hook for a further series of negative media articles stating that the company is being investigated by the prosecutor’s office and the Investigative Committee for suspected violations of specified articles of the Criminal Code.
Even if the company has committed no real violations and the inspection finds nothing, or the prosecutor’s office simply replies that no violations have been identified, a news hook has already been created for reports that law enforcement is investigating the company for legal violations.
And this, again, hits the company’s reputation very hard and drives customers away.
Formal Requests by Legislators as a Method of Legal Pressure
The next method of legal pressure on a company is a formal request from a legislator.
This is one of the rarest and most serious methods of attacking a company. It is very expensive and requires advance preparation involving the fabrication of supporting evidence.
Throughout our agency’s practice, this method has been used only a few times, and only in major integrated black PR campaigns against very powerful market players.
Consider one example from our practice.
We received a request to conduct black PR against an owner of several SPAR stores.
SPAR supermarkets operate under a franchise model, and many stores belong to different owners even though they use the same brand.
As part of a PR campaign to eliminate a competitor, we were commissioned to discredit two stores that had opened under the SPAR brand.
It was necessary to create very serious problems for them: either bring about their closure or force the owner to sell the stores to a larger market player.
We then studied the operations of these two stores in detail.
To find a news hook, we decided to place a journalist in one of the stores undercover as an employee.
We waited several months for a suitable vacancy to open. Eventually, a position became available in the prepared-food department, where our employee was hired.
The employee then simply recorded all instances of unsanitary conditions and violations in the preparation of ready-made food on a phone.
After that, we brought in bloggers who distributed the video online.
This naturally caused a public response, but led to practically no serious consequences for the owner of the stores.
It was therefore decided to use a formal request from a legislator.
We used our contacts to have a formal request from a legislator sent to Rospotrebnadzor, requesting an inspection of these stores’ operations and of all their products’ compliance with sanitary standards.
The legislator’s formal request could not be ignored, so Rospotrebnadzor closed both stores and began inspecting their staff, products and working conditions.
Eventually, expired products that had already been withdrawn from sale were found in the warehouses. Nevertheless, Rospotrebnadzor officers confiscated 600 kilograms of expired food.
In practice, expired products can be found in any ordinary supermarket. This is not in itself a violation, particularly if the products are in a warehouse rather than on the sales floor.
But the legislator’s formal request itself, Rospotrebnadzor’s inspection and the closure of the stores provided a sufficient news hook for a press campaign and caused a major response among residents of the neighborhood where the stores were located.
Without the legislator’s formal request, the story would not have spread so widely or attracted the attention of inspection authorities.
This is a clear example of how a formal request from a legislator helped generate a public response and serious reputational problems for a store.
Conclusion
Thus, black PR against an organization can include not only negative reviews and media publications, but also social media work, offline methods and legal pressure. All these approaches can be used separately or within a single integrated campaign, in which some actions create a news hook, others ensure its distribution, and others force the company to spend time and resources dealing with the resulting problems. The scale and choice of methods depend on the particular organization and the project’s goals.