Black PR against individuals: discrediting a person and undermining their reputation

Discrediting a person: personal and business reputation

Black PR against individuals means targeted work to discredit a person. It can be carried out both online and offline.

Everything depends on the project’s objectives, the person’s activities and the information that needs to be conveyed to the audience.

It is important to distinguish between discrediting business and personal reputations. The first concerns the person’s professional qualities and activities; the second concerns facts from their biography or family relationships.

Attacks on a personal reputation may use information about criminal convictions, infidelity, domestic violence or tyrannical behavior.

Accordingly, black PR methods differ depending on which aspect of the person’s reputation needs to be affected and what results need to be achieved.

More about the concept itself, its types and general principles can be found in ‘What black PR is: methods and examples’. Here, however, we will focus specifically on discrediting a person, rather than a company or brand.

Objectives of black PR against a person

When a client asks us to organize black PR against a particular person, our first step is to determine the ultimate objective.

As a rule, black PR is commissioned either for personal reasons - resentment or a conflict - or for commercial reasons: eliminating a competitor or obtaining another benefit.

The objective determines the black PR methods, target audience and information that needs to be distributed.

Discrediting a person’s professional and business reputation

Discrediting a person’s professional reputation is one of the most common options. It is most often done through reviews and opinions from people who have interacted with the person.

Discrediting a manager through employee reviews

For example, if the person is the head of an organization, the work is usually built around publishing reviews of the company.

These may be reviews by former or current employees mentioning the full name of the manager who is the target of the black PR.

They may claim that a corruption scheme operates within the company, headed by this manager.

The manager may also be accused of harassment, pressuring female employees into sexual relationships or discriminating against colleagues.

Everything depends on the objective set.

Reviews make it possible to discredit a person because, formally, they are published about the organization. The author states that it is uncomfortable to work there specifically because of a particular manager.

For example, the manager obstructs work, creates an unhealthy atmosphere in the team, fines employees or otherwise interferes with normal operations.

The person is thus smeared in reviews by colleagues or subordinates that are formally about the organization.

Discrediting an employee through negative customer reviews

If the business reputation of an employee of a particular organization needs to be tarnished, reviews from customers who worked with them are added to those of colleagues and subordinates.

These describe their work negatively: broken agreements, missed deadlines, indifference, lack of feedback and ignoring customer inquiries.

The content depends on the person’s professional activities.

First, the niche and type of activity are analyzed, and then the negative aspects customers may encounter are identified.

Information is collected about problems experienced by customers of other companies throughout the history of that field.

These situations are then presented as having occurred while working with the particular person.

A separate set of negative aspects is developed for each type of activity, to be used in reviews of the company mentioning that employee.

Black PR against entrepreneurs, bloggers and independent professionals

Further methods depend on the person’s public profile and the nature of their activities.

If the person is a company employee, the methods described above are used. But if they are a director, blogger, course seller or provider of services or goods in their own right, the opportunities for discrediting them are broader.

In particular, reviews can be used, but about the person directly rather than the company. They may also be accused of fraud.

An example of discrediting a lawyer’s reputation

For example, if a lawyer’s reputation needs to be discredited, negative reviews are distributed in a client’s name claiming that the lawyer commits fraud, takes money, fails to attend court hearings and ignores the client, causing them problems.

Another common method is publishing information in the media that the person is a fraudster.

For example, the story of a deceived client is used.

If local search results are needed - for example, for a lawyer working in Nizhny Novgorod - local news websites publish a report that a city resident became the victim of fraudsters who promised a particular result but failed to fulfill their obligations.

Adding a person to blacklists

Another method of discrediting a person’s reputation is adding them to various blacklists.

There are a huge number of blacklists, covering different subjects, professional fields and categories of people about whom information is published.

Blacklists of managers and directors

For example, there are blacklists of managers and directors where employees can post negative reviews of their bosses.

Some reviews are anonymous, while others use real names. In general, however, these sites allow employees to anonymously describe negative experiences of working with a particular manager.

Such reviews may describe conflicts, abuse of authority, an unhealthy team atmosphere, violations of employment rights and other negative aspects of the manager’s activities.

In practice, this allows a person’s professional reputation to be discredited through reviews by their employees and subordinates.

Blacklists of employees and job applicants

There are also employee blacklists to which employers can add negligent workers or job applicants.

In reality, employers quite often encounter unsuitable applicants who try to get a job using fake résumés, listing nonexistent previous employers or invented professional experience.

Similarly, there can be problems with employees dismissed for misconduct or who resigned because the employer could not, for one reason or another, dismiss them on disciplinary grounds.

There are many situations in which employers encounter dishonest employees and suffer certain losses as a result.

This is precisely why specialized employee blacklists exist, publishing information about such people.

We ourselves previously owned a website specializing in employee blacklists, so we are very familiar with this way of working.

Regional and subject-specific blacklists

Beyond professional blacklists, there are a huge number of regional and subject-specific resources.

Examples include a Moscow blacklist, blacklists for individual cities, blacklists of Avito sellers, fraudsters and members of various professions.

Some of these blacklists are independent websites. Others are separate sections of review websites or sites featuring job vacancies and résumés.

There are also a huge number of specialized social media groups.

For example, ‘Blacklist of Fraudsters in Anapa’ is a VKontakte group where posts about people or organizations can be published.

There are many such groups. Relevant specialist platforms can be found for almost every city, field of activity or category of people.

That is why black PR against individuals uses various blacklists that can serve to distribute negative information about a person.

Using blacklists to discredit a particular person

Here, once again, everything depends on the person’s activities, biography and previous workplaces.

Their professional activities are analyzed, previous employers are identified, and the fields in which they worked or were involved are studied.

If the companies where the person previously worked are known, fabricated negative reviews supposedly from those employers may appear on employee blacklists.

If the person pursued a particular activity or had hobbies, negative information about them may be posted on the relevant specialist blacklists and in social media groups and forums.

These publications usually include detailed information that makes it possible to identify the person.

This matters because a negative review must be associated with a particular person, not someone else who may have the same first and last name.

In this way, a negative picture of the person is created online.

When someone enters the person’s full name into a search engine, the results include pages featuring them on various blacklists.

This can create problems when applying for a job, being appointed to a particular position, taking part in elections or carrying out professional activities.

Because an employer’s or security department’s background check will uncover information about the person’s presence on blacklists.

Blacklists concerning debtors and microfinance organizations

Another option is adding the person to blacklists related to debts, loans and microfinance organizations.

Here, the person is discredited by giving them a negative reputation as an unreliable borrower.

A narrative is created suggesting that the person constantly takes out bank loans, approaches various microfinance organizations and does not repay the money received.

Claims are published that debt collectors are supposedly pursuing them, and that they borrow money from acquaintances and do not repay their debts.

Such publications may even include supposed photographs of IOUs, loan agreements and other documents presented as evidence of the debt.

It is fairly difficult for an ordinary person to verify the authenticity of these documents, especially if they do not know what the person’s real handwriting or signature looks like.

As a result, a search by full name may find the person not only on employee and manager blacklists, but also on lists of debtors, unreliable borrowers or people who supposedly fail to meet their financial obligations.

All of this creates additional negativity around their reputation and can affect both their professional activities and their personal and business relationships.

Political black PR: discrediting former officials and politicians

Another example from our work involves political black PR.

The target was a former senator who had already retired. Because of personal animosity, the client decided to organize a campaign against him.

We researched facts from his biography. One area focused on his personal property, or more precisely, the discrepancy between his official income and its value.

Information about registered cars, houses and land plots was obtained from restricted registers.

Because he had previously held public office and filed income declarations, the declarations were compared with the property acquired in the corresponding years.

Declared income was compared with the value of the assets acquired.

Values were estimated using public listings: for example, a similar car from the same year was found on Avito and its price established.

Land plots were valued by their area, location and the prices of comparable plots in the neighborhood. Houses were valued similarly.

We then released a series of articles and a news video stating that the value of the property was several dozen times the person’s lawful income.

The materials were distributed through the media and social networks, generating a public reaction to the corruption allegations.

It did not matter that the person had long been retired. What mattered was the presentation: he had supposedly misappropriated funds while in power, was still enjoying the benefits of those assets and had escaped justice.

Calls were then circulated to hold him accountable and convict him of corruption.

The characteristics of this area are covered in greater detail in the website section ‘Black PR against politicians’.

Distributing compromising material about individuals and creating a news hook

The distribution of negative and compromising information plays the main role in black PR against people. This subject is also covered by the separate service ‘Creating and leaking compromising material’.

Without a news hook, the sudden appearance of negative reviews and mentions raises suspicion.

That is why an important element of black PR against people is creating a news hook.

This means creating an event that may never have actually happened.

Much depends on the capabilities of the agency carrying out the black PR.

A real event from a person’s biography can serve as a news hook: concealing a conviction, a conflict or a scandal.

If no such facts exist, the news hook is created artificially.

Any information can be published in the media, but without supporting evidence it is easy to refute.

For example, accusing a person of alcoholism may lead to a pre-litigation demand or a complaint to the hosting provider or newsroom, after which the publication will be removed.

As a result, it will not achieve the required effect.

Creating a news hook to distribute compromising material

Creating a news hook often involves offline actions.

For example, a scandal is organized.

In one case from our work, a woman was found who contacted law enforcement with a report of attempted rape or threats.

With a limited budget and a little-known person as the target, this could be an online post in the supposed victim’s name.

Information was also circulated that the person had fled a crime scene or traffic accident, or had nearly hit a pedestrian.

Another option is hiring an actor to demand, in front of witnesses, that the target of black PR repay a debt or pay child support.

The content depends on the target. A man may be portrayed as a domestic tyrant, a child-support defaulter or an unfaithful husband.

An actress can be hired to pose as his mistress and contact his wife.

Calls can also be made to his workplace by someone posing as his wife’s lawyer to ask about his salary, whether he was dismissed or other details, claiming that he is concealing income and not paying child support.

In this way, many news hooks can be created against anyone. It is simply a question of choosing the scenario.

Creating a news hook through a pseudo-journalistic investigation

One common method is simultaneously accusing a person of unlawful acts and law enforcement of inaction.

For example, the media publish information that residents of a building are complaining about what is happening in a particular apartment: running a den of illegal activity, selling drugs or committing other violations.

It is claimed that complaints to the local police officer produce no result because he supposedly receives payment and protects the apartment’s owner.

A pseudo-journalistic investigation is then carried out. Journalists report that the apartment belongs to a particular person - the target of black PR - who was supposedly previously involved in unlawful activities.

Interviews with neighbors that never actually took place are published. Instead, a list of questions and answers is written as if they had given the interviews, corroborating the accusations being spread.

The material is published in local news outlets and then distributed through social networks, news groups, classified-ad groups and forums.

This creates the appearance of supporting evidence, because the fact of publication in the media is itself used to substantiate the accusations.

Similar material can be presented in the form of a journalistic investigation or news video.

Discrediting a person offline

Offline discrediting is a separate area requiring an individual approach to each case. Here, the work extends beyond publications and search results. More about this area can be found on the page ‘Offline black PR methods’.

An example of black PR motivated by personal revenge

In one case, a person needed to be discredited in a particular city district. The reason was personal animosity and the client’s desire for revenge.

The PR practitioners proposed spreading information that the person was a pervert and a pedophile.

First, leaflets with his photograph were placed near playgrounds, supermarkets and parking areas, and on poles and at bus stops.

The headline warned that a pedophile had supposedly appeared in the neighborhood.

The text said that anyone encountering this person near a child should drive him away and contact the police.

It also described invented incidents of attempts to lure a child into an apartment or car and touching intimate body parts.

The leaflets were distributed in the person’s neighborhood.

At night, the word ‘pedophile’ was painted on his car.

Social media were then brought into the campaign: district and city news groups, classified-ad groups, buy-and-sell groups, parent communities, school chats, forums and other platforms.

These spread information that the person was a pedophile and described invented incidents of his alleged sexual harassment of children.

It was also claimed that attempts had been made to open a criminal case against him, but he had supposedly paid his way out or escaped responsibility because of insufficient evidence.

The approach relied primarily on anxiety among parents.

Posts from fictitious female profiles claimed that the person handed out sweets to children and was often near a school or playground.

For this, fictitious accounts were created listing the target’s city of residence, and these stories were spread through those accounts.

This gave him a reputation as a pedophile.

Calls were then made to his workplace by people posing as journalists, asking for comment on the rumors. Employees were asked whether they had noticed suspicious behavior, how the person behaved at work and what personal qualities he had.

In fact, the employees were being questioned by specially hired people posing as journalists.

The aim was to convey the accusations to colleagues and management, creating additional problems at work.

Thus, discrediting took place not only where the person lived, but also in their professional environment.

Setting someone up as a method of discrediting their reputation

Another method of discrediting is setting someone up.

This can be done both online and offline.

Setting someone up through fake social media accounts

The simplest online setup is copying a person’s photographs and creating pages in their name on social networks, specialist websites and dating sites.

The person is then discredited through actions taken using these accounts.

For example, to portray a husband as unfaithful, a dating-site profile is created where he supposedly communicates with other women.

His photographs are uploaded to the profile, and the page is then presented as genuine.

In these messages, he may supposedly send intimate photographs that actually belong to another person.

Such actions are often directed at minors.

In the target’s name or through a copy of their account, minors may be offered money for sex or intimate photographs, or pressured into other actions.

This creates a news hook and provokes a response from parents or the children themselves.

Screenshots may also be created and claims spread about the person’s supposedly immoral behavior.

Discrediting women through fake profiles on dating and escort websites

The same method is used against women.

Profiles on dating and escort websites, as well as advertisements with her photographs, are created in a woman’s name.

This creates the appearance of evidence that she posts these advertisements herself and offers escort services.

A news story may then be published claiming that a foreigner contacted the police after a prostitute supposedly got him drunk, robbed him and infected him with sexually transmitted diseases.

He supposedly has no information about the woman other than a photograph and phone number.

A journalist supposedly identifies her from the phone number, publishes photographs and refers to profiles and images found on specialist websites.

The profiles initially created to discredit the woman are thus used as evidence of her supposed involvement in escort services.

Why attempts to clear one’s name can intensify negative publicity

It is almost impossible for the person to clear their name.

When they try to explain that it was not them and that they were set up, the audience may view such statements with even greater distrust.

By entering the information battle and trying to defend themselves, they actually help spread the negative information, because they bring the topic back into focus and draw more attention to it.

Manipulating negative search suggestions for a person’s full name

Another method of discrediting an individual’s reputation is manipulating search suggestions for their full name.

What is that?

When a query is entered into any search engine’s search bar, the search engine offers additional suggestions for that query.

For example, if you enter a person’s full name and they are well known, the search engine will suggest additional words: biography, concerts, personal life, family, business and so on.

This helps refine the search query and make the results more relevant.

Using this mechanism, black PR employs a method in which negative search suggestions are added to a person’s full name.

What is meant by negative?

For example, take someone called Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov. When a person enters his full name, after the search suggestions have been manipulated, the search engine starts offering additional queries:

  • Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov court
  • Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov fraudster
  • Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov criminal cases
  • Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov scandal
  • Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov wanted

Even before receiving any search results, the user already concludes that this is a scandalous and, to put it mildly, not particularly good person, given these search suggestions.

This is the simplest version of the method.

The main point is that there is no need even to distribute any news. Simply manipulating the search suggestions is enough.

But when a fairly substantial PR campaign is carried out against a person, articles on news websites, social media posts and comments mentioning the person’s full name and the relevant negative wording are also published for each such negative search suggestion.

Thus, after entering the person’s full name, the user sees negative search suggestions.

Curiosity leads them to click on one, such as ‘Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov fraudster’, and immediately see search results containing a whole set of websites where Ivan Ivanovich is mentioned as a fraudster.

More about search queries, publication visibility and work with search results can be found on the page ‘Work with search results’.

Discrediting a person’s reputation through their phone number

The next method of black PR against an individual involves their phone number.

For example, a website is created with a domain name matching the person’s phone number.

What does that mean?

We can register a domain, for example, using the number 7-906-123-4-2-4-5.

A domain matching the person’s phone number is registered. Different domain extensions can be used: .com, .org, .net and others.

Negative information directly about the person, including compromising material, is then placed on this domain.

When people enter the person’s phone number into a search engine, this website containing negative information about the number’s owner may appear first.

The effect is actually quite substantial.

Because a great many people search online for mentions of a phone number, its registration details and who owns it.

Even when someone knows who owns the phone number, they may still use it to search for additional information.

And this is one method of black PR.

Posting advertisements with the black PR target’s phone number

There is also an extension of this method in which the person’s phone number is used as the contact number in various advertisements.

Advertisements offering services are posted with this number on various classified-ad sites, in groups and on forums.

The person has nothing to do with posting these advertisements.

As part of the PR campaign, the black PR agency’s employees post various advertisements themselves, giving the target’s phone number.

When people start calling this number, first of all, the person does not understand what the callers are talking about.

Secondly, they start being rude, saying that the caller has the wrong number, that they do not provide these services, and so on.

At the very least, it irritates them.

At the other extreme, it creates additional supposed evidence that the person is a fraudster.

Because an advertisement can be posted with their phone number, followed by reviews claiming that people tried to buy something, transferred money for services and received nothing.

These reviews state that the transfer was made through the Faster Payments System using that phone number.

This creates additional negativity around the person, both through the phone number itself and through the history of advertisements featuring it.

Discrediting an entrepreneur through the phone number used for payments

There is another side to this.

For example, a person sells goods or services and genuinely accepts payments through the Faster Payments System using their phone number.

They simply give the customer a phone number and say: ‘Here, transfer 100 rubles to this number.’

Accordingly, when a domain matching this phone number is created and states that the number’s owner is a fraudster, people see the information and refuse to transfer money to them.

Because they believe the person is a fraudster and already see supposed evidence of fraud in the form of negative reviews.

Thus, discrediting through a phone number can affect not only a person’s personal reputation but also their commercial activities directly.

Discrediting through a person’s biography and professional profiles

The next black PR method is used mainly against public figures, directors, business owners, famous personalities and other prominent people, such as major businesspeople.

As a rule, these people have biographies published on various websites.

For example, this may be an employee biography describing their professional achievements on the company’s website.

Or there are professional websites such as LinkedIn featuring the person’s résumé.

There are also specialist websites that publish people’s biographies.

The person’s real biography is taken, and negative facts are added to it.

For example, that the person has a criminal conviction, was involved in a corruption scandal or was dismissed on disciplinary grounds over allegations of theft, corrupt ties or involvement in corruption schemes.

In practice, any negative details that can be invented about the person are added to the biography.

Moreover, biographical facts often do not even require evidence.

Because when people look for a person’s biography and find it on specialist websites, they always assume it has been checked, is accurate and comes from a reliable source.

And when journalists write articles, they often take information about a person from publicly available biographies without even checking it.

This is one of the most suitable methods for adding invented negative details to a person’s biography.

However, the facts do not even have to be invented.

In reality, many people have at least one biographical fact they try to hide, avoid talking about or keep out of the public domain.

That fact can be used by actively spreading it and making it widely known.

Distributing a negative biography on specialist websites

In addition to spreading negative facts, the altered biography itself is placed on all kinds of websites.

Many websites allow biographies to be posted free of charge. Major websites also publish biographies for a fee.

But overall, given the budget and the desire, a great many unverified biographies can be placed on all kinds of authoritative websites, thereby creating primary sources.

If we need to publish something negative about a person in an official media outlet, we can use their biography as the primary source.

For example, if we need to spread information that the person has a criminal conviction.

This can be relevant in work against politicians, shareholders or others who need to be discredited before an event, especially if a criminal conviction bars them from a particular activity, position or party membership.

In that case, details of a fictitious conviction are added to the biography, after which the altered version is published on various websites.

The media then spread information that the person has a criminal conviction but is trying to take a position, run for office or conceal the conviction.

The biography on a specialist website, which says the person really has that conviction, is cited as the primary source.

Information about court cases, lawsuits and similar matters can be mentioned in the same way.

Using biography websites as primary sources for the media

For many media outlets, the existence of such a primary source will count as supporting evidence, and they will not check the biography itself.

Because, first of all, criminal conviction records are restricted.

An ordinary person cannot simply submit a request and find out whether someone else has a criminal conviction. This is confidential information.

This is precisely why people are asked for a certificate of no criminal record when applying for a job or in other situations.

Such a certificate is issued directly to the person, or information is provided in response to requests from authorized law enforcement bodies.

So it is practically impossible for an ordinary citizen to check whether another person has a criminal conviction.

Journalists writing for the media may simply use a third-party biography website as their primary information source.

The assumption behind this scheme is that they thereby eliminate all their legal risks.

Because when they receive a pre-litigation demand over defamatory content - since the person genuinely has no conviction - they will point out that the conviction information was taken from another website.

The person is therefore told to take the matter up directly with that website.

The website itself may remove the conviction details from the biography quite quickly once a certificate of no criminal record is provided.

But the problem is that this is only one website.

Most often, the altered biography is published on a huge number of websites.

The number of websites carrying such biographies can reach 30–50.

It all depends on the budget of the company carrying out the black PR.

At that point, it becomes very difficult for the person to prove that they have no conviction.

Other black PR methods and examples from our work

This article has examined methods of discrediting a person through reviews, blacklists, compromising material, staged news hooks, biographical publications, social media, search suggestions and phone numbers.

Individual areas are presented in detail on the website: creating and leaking compromising material, distribution of compromising material, journalistic investigations, work with search results, offline black PR methods and political black PR.

All the main areas are gathered in the service catalogue; real stories can be found in the “Case studies” section.